Payment and Cancellation Policy



Abel's Acres Retreat House

Abel's Acres Hideaway

Alana Bertch Cottage

Alexis Carriage House

Alice's Lake House

All About the Game

Anita's Acres

Anne's Place

Applefield Guest House

Applefield Homestead

Arnoldson House

Around the Corner

Ballpark Holiday

Bliss House

Bliss Dugout


Budine's Retreat

Busy Bee I

Busy Bee II

Calla Lily Apt 1

Calla Lily Apt 2

Camp Run-A-Muck

Canadarago Lake Cottage

Captain's Lookout

Center City Inn

Charlotte Creek Apt

Charlotte Creek House

Charlotte Valley Cottage

Cottage on Summit Lake

Creekside Haven

Duke's Pond I-Cottage

Duke's Pond II-Cabin

Dutch Hill Farm

Field of Dreams 

Goose Bay

Hope House

Lake House

Lakeview Pines

Maple Row Hideaway

McClure House

Milford House-1st Base

Milford House-3rd Base

Milford House - Bleachers

Nazarene House

Park Place - Bombay

Park Place - Mandalay

Park Place - Rhodesia

Patent Cabin One

Patent Cabin Two

Pine Ridge Lodge

Pleasant Valley Pines

Roundabout Apts 1,2,3,4

Sideline Apt

Silver House

Silver House-Efficiency

Sunnycrest-1st Base

Sunnycrest-2nd Base

Sunnycrest-3rd Base

Sunnyside Hollow
Farm - I

Sunnyside Hollow
Farm - II

Techa's Apt I

Techa's Apt II

The Perch

The Rookie

The Triple Play

The Woods

Top of the Pines

Two Rivers Farmhouse

Two Rivers Apt

Wake Robin Guest House

Walnut Ridge

Whitfield Apartment

Whitfield House

Wildflower Cottage

Willow Haven

Young Lake House


Applefield Houses



I just wanted to let you know that Kinch's Kountry Acres was wonderful!! Thanks so much! I will remember you if I know of anyone coming up that way or if I decide to revisit myself.

-- Amanda Edenfield

"Jim and June,

We just got home from our trip to Cooperstown Dreams Park and wanted to thank you for the great accommodations. The three ladies that stayed at your Applefield Guest House thought that they received a great place to stay at a great price. The cabin was clean and roomy with a gorgeous view. We will definitely recommend you to the future teams from Sandwich, MA that are heading out to Cooperstown.

Thank you again and feel free to share this message with any prospective vacationers.

-- Chris Russell"


Captain's Lookout

237 Lakeshore Drive South

Maryland, NY 12116

Call 607-435-3244 to Book


Perched above Goodyear Lake, any captain has an awesome view of the lake and the hills beyond.  Renovated in 2014, this waterfront home has a series of decks overlooking the water, and there is room for grilling and dining on the top deck.  There are two kayaks for guests to use at the waterfront, and they can easily be launched off the bulkhead.


This waterfront home is nestled into the hillside with the main living areas and two bedrooms on the top floor-street level.  Two more bedrooms are below the main living areas.  there is a foosball table and sitting area in one of the lower bedrooms.  the yard in front of the home is large enough for playng a game of catch.  There are 5 flat screen TVs - one in the living room and one in each bedroom.


5 flat screen cable TVs, WiFi, Central AC, Whirlpool Tub

15 mins to Dreams Park and 20 mins to All Star Village



Spacious living room with large flat screen cable TV and wet bar.  Attractive hardwood and tile floors throughout.




Main (street) level:  kitchen, dinette, dining room, living room,

two queen bedrooms, each with a full bath 



Dining room and also a dinette area with large capacity washer and dryer.

  Beautiful state of the art kitchen-all the appliances and supplies you could need.  

Two queen bedrooms on the main level, each with an attached full bathroom. 

Also an additional bathroom with whirlpool tub islocated on the main floor and open to the hallway.



All bathrooms are up-to-date

  and beautifully tiled!



Lower Level:   Two king bedrooms each with an attached full bathroom.

                    Also additional kitchen and laundry, plus foosball table




Two king bedrooms on the lower level - each with an attached full bathroom  


The lower level also has a kitchen and a washer and dryer - plus a foosball table and sitting area in one of the lower bedrooms.


Dining table and chairs on the main deck with gas barbecue, and more seating on the lower level with a beautiful view of the lake.


This is a very peaceful and clean lake for swimming, fishing, boating, or just relaxing and enjoying the beautiful scenery and wildlife.



2100 square feet of house plus decks and stairs to private waterfront with bulkhead - 2 kayaks, swimming, fishing, awesome views

                                    No Smoking, No Pets and No Team Parties.

                       "Our rates are reasonable because we value your business                      


Payment & Cancellation Policy


Summer Weekly Rates
Friday after 5 p.m - Friday before 9 a.m


Captain's Lookout -  $3600

Hall of Fame Week:  $4600

$360 security deposit upon arrival

MasterCard, Visa, & Personal Checks Welcome

Maximum Occupancy:    9
County Tourism Tax will be added.
10%  Cancellation Fee


  = Available

Availability for
Captain's Lookout